Showing posts with label sls. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sls. Show all posts

Sunday, August 10, 2014

Commercial 130+ Metric Tonne Rocket Competition Imagined

COTS; Courtesy of NASA
The current Space Launch System (SLS) rocket that is in development is a 70 metric tonne vehicle.  By comparison, SpaceX's Falcon Heavy is a 53 metric tonne rocket.  The Falcon Heavy is slated to make its maiden flight towards the end of 2014.  SLS is slated for a 2017 maiden flight, but that time seems to be slipping.  These dates often slip, even for commercial companies like SpaceX.  The SLS program is also slated to create a 130 metric tonne rocket to explore the solar system.  Consider that commercial space services have already been successful and saved NASA money.  Consider also that a new space services market has been created and is growing.  I do not think that SLS will survive long in a commercial space services dominant environment.  I think a competition for a 130 metric tonne rocket is in order for NASA.

In 2006 NASA's Commercial Cargo & Crew Program Office (C3PO) created the Commercial Orbital Transportation Services (COTS) which was a competition for companies to create rockets and spacecraft to provide the International Space Station (ISS) with cargo.  COTS also lead to Commercial Resupply Services (CRS) which was the operational missions to supply the cargo.  While there were many entrants into COTS, including Boeing and Lockheed Martin, SpaceX and Orbital Sciences won, and are supplying cargo today.  The CRS contracts were fixed price versus the traditional Cost Plus contracts which is how SLS is being developed.  Under CRS the companies retain ownership of their rockets and spacecraft, and also the risk associated with development and operation.  Risk is one of the potentially most costly aspect of any project or program.  By giving companies the risk, NASA has also given the companies freedom for innovation.  Essentially NASA has helped create new competition in the space launch world and has saved money at the same time.  SpaceX's Dragon first berthed with ISS in 2012.  Orbital Sciences' Cygnus first berthed with ISS in 2013.  The success of COTS is historic for the planet.  For the first time, orbital commercial services became a reality.

Think of the future where commercial space companies dominate launch and operation services. What place does a costly SLS have in this environment?  Already Falcon Heavy encroaches on the lifting capability of the 70 metric tonne SLS.  SpaceX has plans to launch cargo and people to Mars.  They will make a very large rocket that competes with 130 metric tonne SLS.  What future does SLS have?  Even is SLS functions perfectly, its cost will make it obsolete.  With a constraint budget, NASA would be tempted to launch the Orion Multipurpose Crew Vehicle (MPCV) on a commercial launch service.  They might even be tempted to use a commercial capsule for missions like a new version of SpaceX's Dragon.  To me, the mighty dollar is going to doom SLS the scrap heap.

In the aerospace industry, competitions is what spur innovation and development.  Charles Lindbergh won the Ortieg prize in 1927 by crossing the Atlantic Ocean in a non-stop flight with his plane the Spirit Of St Louis.  This resulted in our current transatlantic flight market.  This also resulted in round the world air commercial air travel.  Burt Rutan's Scaled Composites won the X-Prize in 2004 by flying their space craft SpaceShipOne to suborbital space twice in a two week period.  This has spurred the new commercial space market.  Now Virgin Galactic, Xcor, and others are competing for customers for their first suborbital passenger space flights.  These competitions work.  Let us go a step further and make a competition that will result in more than one commercial launch system of 130 metric tonnes or greater.

Why would we need such monster rockets you may ask.  Commercially, the bigger the rocket, the less money per kilogram is needed to launch anything.  Who would use these?  Besides NASA, there are current companies and organizations with big plans and ideas.  Bigelow Aerospace makes inflatable habitat modules for future commercial space stations/space ships/moon bases.  The Mars Society members long to get to Mars.  Google Lunar Xprize participants have big plans for the Moon. B612 is an organization with a mission to help protect Earth from asteroids. Our current rocket only can start these big ideas.  These represent many people from many countries.  They want to go to space.  They need very large rockets to get to their endgame.

As wonderful an idea SLS is, it is just not cut out for the future that is just around the corner.  If NASA is not relieved of the burden of a 130 metric tonne SLS, the agency will be bypassed by commercial companies in the field of exploration.  NASA should take the lead in exploration, not lag behind.  They should not make any more rockets.  They should hold a competition to develop 130+ metric tonne rockets.  Then they could use those commercial rockets and services to get their spacecraft out in the solar system.  Then they can make more of the wonderful discoveries they have been doing since the 1970s.  These discoveries have helped people on Earth through the decades.  New discoveries can only help those on Earth and those out in the solar system.

Thursday, July 31, 2014

Congress is at it again....SLS underfunded.

Well, here we are again.  For some reason, Congress cannot fund a rocket once it demands it.  Congress should desist from demanding rockets from NASA.  Somebody please sue Congress for overstepping their constitutional bounds.

On July 23rd, 2014, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) said that NASA didn't have enough money to complete the Space Launch System (SLS) in time for the 2017 first launch of the rocket according to Marcia S. Smith's of SpacePolicyOnline.com article entitled "GAO Warns NASA $400 Million Short to Finish SLS by 2017" (click here to see article).  What the hell?

The NASA Authorization Act of 2010 "required immediate development" of the SLS.  Where does it say in the Constitution that Congress can require development of anything?  Such a demand would lie in the executive branch of government, not the legislation.  Well, legally I'm sure I am wrong here, but logically I am right.  NASA, DARPA, and other government research agencies ought to be directed by the executive branch only and not by the legislative.  The reason is obvious, research drives military power and economic health of the nation.  Yes, it's national security.  See, I think economic health should be a part of national security and not just national secrets.  Yet, we have to live with these short sited authorization acts.  Ideally, any legislation authorizing money to a very large project ought to grantee funding for the projected life of the porject.  But the authorization act of 2010 only gave money to 2013. What the hell! 

 I knew this was coming, and when it came I still felt mad and betrayed.  This is exactly why we are not further in our space program as we expected to be.  This questionable way of financing large NASA projects puts into question Congress' concern for the nation's welfare.  This system is broken.  It needs to be redone, rethought over.  I think its time for the US people to start thinking of better ways to proceed in space.  The space research has expanded to a point where there is more space projects than there is available money.  There are commercial alternatives now to launching spacecraft.  There are new spacecraft designs with cost in mind.  Tell Congress to grow a brain and get smarter about space.  It's no longer about jobs in a particular state.  It's about the economy as a whole benefiting from research that is waiting to be done.

Monday, March 18, 2013

A Rocketless NASA?

SLS courtesy NASA
NASA is currently working on making the Space Launch System (SLS).  It's the latest rocket system that the government is working on to create.  The last one, was the Constellation program which failed.  Before that, the Space Transport System (Shuttle) was made in the 1970's by NASA.  Sure many companies were involved in these programs across the country, just like with the Apollo rockets.  This gives NASA full control and responsibility of success and failure with these systems.  Is this really the best thing that NASA could do?  Is NASA wasting their time?  I think NASA should get out of the rocket development business altogether.  Case in point, I found this article in Al.com (Alabama) by Lee Roop.  In it, some members of Congress state that SLS is too expensive.  Here we go again.  It's financial crunch just like in Constellation.  I'm starting to have doubts that SLS will ever fly.  NASA's strength is research for aerospace companies, and provide opportunity for scientific experiments off the planet.  They also do good in space exploration, manned and unmanned.  Why not have NASA major on these strengths rather than developing rockets while Congress refuses to fund NASA appropriately?  Much scientific experimentation is refused because of lack of money available.  Commercial Space can take over the development and responsibility for launches as they are demonstrating today.  They already are taking pressurized cargo to the ISS.  They are slated to take astronauts to ISS as well.  Let's see what we got as far as rockets and what a rocketless NASA would look like where it comes to space exploration.

So far, the major commercial players to launch NASA assets into orbit are ULA, Orbital Sciences, and SpaceX.  These guys represent the current launch might of the United States.  The rockets are:

ULA
Orbital Sciences
SpaceX
Atlas V is being upgraded to be human rated to compete with Falcon 9.  Antares is also competing with Falcon 9 but in the pressurized cargo area.  ULA is a cooperation between Boeing and Lockheed Martin.  Before SpaceX, only Atlas V, the Delta family and Oribtal's rockets (not Antares) were the launchers plus NASA had Shuttle (STS).  Shuttle is gone.  You see that the commercial companies are responding to NASA's need and challenge to assist in the manned exploration effort already.

If NASA never gets SLS, how could it explore asteroids and Mars?  SLS represents an approach that was used for Apollo.  That approach was to put all your assets on one BIG ROCKET and go for your target.  Man has never been manlier (that's a joke).  There is another theoretical approach but it's never been tried.  That approach requires the use of medium size rockets (Atlas V, Delta IV, Falcon 9).  The idea is to use more than one launch to Earth orbit and put together your stack that goes to your target in orbit.  That stack would have a rocket big enough to leave Earth orbit, carry all the assets needed for the mission including a capsule to return the crew back to earth.  This would give commercial companies contracts and responsibility for launches.  Plus the old axiom is put to use that says "don't put all your eggs in one basket".  Launch from Earth represents the most risk to hardware and crew on any mission apart from landing.  Does this seem inefficient?  Perhaps to a rocket scientist, but it just may very well be more economically feasible than the alternative.

What about Orion?  The Orion capsule is the only asset to come out of the Constellation program to survive, albeit modified.  It is slated to launch on a Delta IV Heavy for its first space test run and return at high speed through the atmosphere.  That tells me it doesn't need SLS to get to orbit.  Delta IV or Falcon Heavy are capable of handling the job.

What could this stack look like?  If you look at SLS, the stack could be the upper stage that uses the J-2X engine, whatever space module needed form the mission, and the Orion Command Module.  2 or 3 launches should do the trick.  Later, they could make the J-2X booster into a reusable booster that comes back to Earth orbit ready to be refueled for another mission.

SLS is based on old idea of space operations.  This is a new century.  NASA has bigger plans for exploration than is SLS can economically provide.  SLS is really putting money in a rocket that is seldom going to be used.  That makes no economic sense.  NASA should stop reinventing the rocket.

NASA without its own rocket could open up the architecture of a mission to become more economically feasible, more reliable, and more evolvable.  I say let commercial companies lift NASA to orbit.  Then NASA can take care of exploration from there.

Sunday, January 20, 2013

Space Exploration Plans From Boeing

I read in a NASA Spaceflight.com article that Boeing came out with a moon exploration plan.  The plan entails a small space station put at Earth Moon Lagrange Point 2 (EML2).  That's a region of space past the dark side of the moon.  From there you can have a variety of missions ranging from moon missions to asteroid missions to mars missions.  We're told to think of it as a staging area.  It's supposed to be easy to get to and not that much fuel is needed.  They call it Earth Moon Lagrange point Platform (EMLP).  Then Boeing came out with a Mars exploration plan as stated in this NASA Spaceflight.com article.  They use the EML2 as a staging are to launch to Mars with a combination of chemical and ion propulsion system craft.  Are these a good ideas?  I tend to think that it is, but I'm also a little skeptic.

Sure it seems you can do it all with these plans, but at what cost?  SLS doesn't promise to be economical.  It will take several launches of SLS to make the Moon plan work.  It will also take several (at least 2) launches of the same rocket to make the Mars plan work even after the EMLP has been established.  The only reusable part of the SLS are its solid rocket boosters.  At least in the moon plan a reusable moon lander is called for, and the EMLP is designed to be a multi-mission asset.  These plans call for many in-space and landing assets to be built.  This is not cheap.  I am also skeptic about this Mars lander that is supposed to land and launch astronauts on to and from the Martian surface.  How big does that thing need to be?  How much fuel does it need?  Mars is about one third of the gravity of Earth.  Sp they seem to need one third of the energy of a Earth based rocket to get to orbit.  Like a third of a Falcon 9.  I'm just guessing here, the details I'm sure are different due in part Mars' gravitational field's profile (gravity is not linear with altitude).  Yet, it gives you an idea of the problem.  Think of all that hardware and fuel launching from Earth, in parts, and sending off to Mars.  Its huge!  The Mars plan seems to imply that the large transfer vehicle is for only one use, and one mission.  So if we want to make another go at it, we need to spend a lot of money to do so.

Apollo used all throw away assets to do its 7 moon landings.  It was canceled due to cost.  I hold the philosophy that space assets should and ought to be reusable, that is used for more than one mission.  The trans-lunar injection was performed by Saturn V's third stage.    That function can be made by a reusable space tug.  A reusable space tug would be equipped with propulsion (chemical, ion, and/or plasma), communication, and power (solar or nuclear).  They would dock with a manned capsule or cargo capsule/canister and take them to their destination.  I don't see why NASA does not pursue this route rather than majoring on throw away assets.  A reusable space tug can take crew, cargo, and/or modules from Earth orbit to Lunar or Martian orbits and return to Earth orbit.  Then they could be refueled and loaded up with a payload and do the next mission.  The only thing that has not been mastered in this sequence is an unmanned tug returning to Earth orbit.  Yet, space programs do have experience getting into Mar's orbit and using aerobraking to do it.  Similar techniques could be used with the tug.  Of course, when its taking a capsule back to Earth, the capsule would disengage the tug before the tug maneuvers to Earth orbit because it could take weeks for the tug to get to low orbit.  NASA could make its own, or a company can make its own and sell the services to NASA.  I wonder if some company out there is doing just that?  I don't know.  I did think up this reusable tug idea back in 2004 when SpaceShipOne was making its historical flights.  I posted this idea on Space.com forums at the time.  It seems that NASA thought of the Space Tug concept too in 1969.  These tugs could be of variable sizes for a variety of missions for many customers.  They could go to Moon, Mars, Venus, Mercury, the Asteroid Belt, and even the gas giants.  They could form an effective fleet for space exploration and commercial exploitation such as mining.  I imagine that reusable in-space assets, such as the space tug, could bring down the cost of traveling to the Moon and Mars significantly since the commercial launch companies can also leverage their launch capabilities.

Yes, the Boeing plans are cool.  I believe they will be too costly for Congress to flip the bill.  Making good use of the new commercial space approach with reusable assets could make the missions cheaper and help keep them going for a long time.