Showing posts with label space operation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label space operation. Show all posts

Thursday, March 19, 2015

Jupiter Spacecraft - Proposed Reusable Tug

Well, someone has heard.  Someone has come to reason.  In the Tech Times article called Lockheed Martin In Collision Course With SpaceX In Providing Reusable Spaceflight Architecture by Sumit Passary, Lockheed Martin is proposing a reusable space tug to compete in the new cargo resupply contracts bid to the ISS coming up.  I first wrote about a tug that was very similar in January of 2013 in my post Space Exploration Plans From Beoing.  I am happy to see that someone is taking the idea seriously.  This proposal is sophisticated and versatile enough for future infrastructure in space.

Locheed Martin calls it Jupiter spacecraft.  It has solar panels, propulsion (chemical), a robotic arm, and a refueling system.  Once in orbit, it will receive canisters called Exoliners one at a time.  After delivering the initial Exoliner with which Jupiter is launched,  Jupiter will rendezvous and capture the subsequent Exoliners for deliver.  Exoliners can also be deorbited as trash.  This is a very sophisticated if not complicated procedure.  Where is the refueling coming from?  I'm sure the Jupiter spacecraft is getting its fuel from the Exoliners.  Sure, it's not straight forward like Cygnus or Dragon cargo spacecraft, but the benefit is that it is reusable which brings down the launch weight and subsequently the cost.

Now, a craft like this can operate for years.  It may out live the ISS and start servicing other missions like a Bigelow Aerospace commercial space station.  The technology could be expanded into satellite repair/refuel.  It can also be upgraded to service flights to the Moon and back.  Such a technology is quite versatile.  It can not only move cargo pressurized or not, but also space capsules carrying people to higher orbits, different orbits, to asteroids, or the Moon.  It can expand our presence in space.  The idea of automated space tugs is not a new one, but this is the first commercially proposed one.

Jupiter/Exoliner space tug system is sophisticated, versatile, and commercial.  I'm happily surprised that Locheed Martin came up with the proposal.  Now, if they would only replace their venerable and rapidly obselete Atlas V with a reusable rocket that uses more principles from my Space Faring Standards post, they would be set.




Tuesday, March 17, 2015

Set Orbit Around Ceres

Courtesy of NASA
Dawn, the amazing unmanned spacecraft at the command of Marc Rayman as Mission Director and Dr. Chris Russell as the Principal Investigator with thier crew of scientists and engineers, has entered into orbit around Ceres.  This is a remarkable achievement as it is the first time in human history that an unmanned spacecraft has entered into orbit around a second space body in one mission.  Dawn was able to do this thanks to its multiple ion drives.  Dawn is an amazing spacecraft and will likely find new discoveries at Ceres.

No other spacecraft has been as powerful or versatile as Dawn.  It has been in orbit around the asteroid Vesta and has made geologic observations with spectrographic data.  Then it left Vesta and made its way to Ceres, a 30 month journey.  It did encounter equipment failures, but the crew was able to work around them to keep the mission alive.

Ceres is currently labeled as a Dwarf Planet.  That is the same label Pluto ended up with.  There are other Dwarf Planets of lesser notoriety.  Dawn will take some time to close its orbit around Ceres to get good image resolutions.  Ceres is already causing mystery.  It is sporting a bright spot or two that is making people get messed up hair from all the scratching.  I'm sure conspiracy theorists and ufologist are loving this.  Yep, drama may ensue.

So finding new discoveries at Ceres and being just amazing I think Dawn is flipping the bill.  For sure it is a mission to keep track of.  So here is to the venerable crew of Dawn.  Live long and prosper.

Friday, December 26, 2014

Space Faring Standards

IF we want to be a space faring people, we HAVE to adopt new launch vehicle standards.  This has become painfully obvious to me this fall with that failure of the Antares rocket and the political fallout of the RD-180 rocket engine which makes the Atlas V as useless as if it had a catastrophic in-flight failure.  You can say this sentiment has been building since SpaceX arrived on the scene and Elon Musk talked about improving the rocket.  I see it now.  I see how deficient our rockets have been.  The rocket is basically in a state that the automobile was in the pre-Model T period.  They are costly and unreliable.  They are toys for the rich.  Small efforts have been attempted to bring the launch price down.  The only company that is bringing prices significantly down is SpaceX.  Those prices still need to come down MORE.  SpaceX can't do it alone either.  There needs to be more companies in the effort.  Well, I came up with some standards to start with that should get us in the right direction.  Of course this is just my own opinion.  They cover items from payload to the first stage.

1.  The payload needs to be recoverable in all phases of flight.  Capsules with crews have had abort systems which were high speed rockets that separated the payload (capsule and crew) form the failing rocket and allowing the parachutes to activate and bring the payload safely to the ground.  Why don't we have this on unmanned payloads?  Unmanned payloads today just blowup with the rest of the rocket in case of an abort.  Thus making vapors out of hopes and investments.  Then the insurance companies have to pony up cash.  I have no doubt this drives up cost of launch to some degree.  If some degree of recovery of the payload could be guaranteed I bet cost would come down.

2.  The upper stage needs to be able to orbit the Earth and make a reentry and landing back to it launch site to be able to reuse.  This is a plan for SpaceX.  They want to make the second stage of the Falcon 9 rocket reusable.  They want it to land after a launch back to base, preferably.  Today, all second stages are discarded after launch.  This means all that hardware has to be created from scratch and tested for ever launch.  That's a lot of man hours.  That's a lot of material.  That's a lot of money.  It's just a bad way to operate.  We've just been operating like that since the beginning of the space age.  The one exception would be the Space Transportation System which, arguably, had an orbiter that was held the payload and was also the second stage.  It was totally reusable.  It's drawback was that there was a lot of maintenance to it to get ready for the next flight.  Yet, overall reuseability should bring down the price of each launch.  Beneficial reuseability was demonstrated in the suborbital world with SpaceShipOne in 2004.

3.  The first stage needs to be able to lift the upper stage and the payload to a certain altitude guaranteed even in the event of an engine failure.  One rocket today meets this standard.  That rocket is the Falcon 9.  It demonstrated it in Oct 2012 where one Merlin engine shut down.  The rocket kept on flying and thanks to its design got it main payload to the International Space Station.  If that happened to any other rocket, the mission would have been a total failure.  The Falcon 9 can do this feat because it has 9 rockets which allows it to loose one or two engines before mission failure.  This needs to be a standard in all future rockets.  The area from the launchpad to the altitude where the second stage can ignite is a critical one.  The Earth is the most dangerous object to a flying rocket.  The more distance it can get away from the planet the safer it is.  That's why this standard is so important.  It give a high degree of guarantee to get to that second stage at a reasonable cost.

4.  The fist stage needs to be recoverable in one piece and reusable.  No one has ever accomplished this.  Oh, now your thinking about the SRBs in the STS.  Well, those were not reused in one piece. They were broken down and rebuilt.  I'm not talking about breaking down and rebuilding.  I'm talking about launch, land, recover, refuel, and launch again.  SpaceX is trying to learn how to do this.  They are currently trying to land their first stage on a large barge in the ocean.  Nobody else is even trying.  Well, Blue Origin was proported as wanting to accomplish this but they are not releasing where they are at or how far they got.  With them it has been so long that I can only conclude they were unable to finish the project.  First stage reuseablility is essential to bring down prices.  It represents the biggest hardware in the rocket stack.  It is only a suborbital vehicle by itself.

5.  Intensive and comprehensive checks on first stage, and upper stage systems need to be done at the launch time where the computer has the ability to abort at the sign of any failed test.  Most, if not all, mainstream rockets have implemented this standard to some degree or another.  The more successful the rocket, the more comprehensive their computerized checks are.  This stands to reason.  This is why there are delays at launch time.  Though they may be a little frustrating, I take the delays as a sign that the checks and tests are working and working hard.  It is a good thing.  Could Antares have used more comprehensive checks and tests to avoid its catastrophic failure?  Possibly.  Time will tell.  As far as I can tell, these tests and checks have become more and more computerized over the years.  Where many of them were just people staring at numbers on a screen to see if they see any anomalies.  This is thanks to miniaturization of the computer circuits on silicon chips and more sophisticated software.  Progress in this area should continue.  We need to get smarter software and more powerful computers as time goes on.  I have no doubt this trend will continue.  So this standard is the one standard that is being implemented by all successful launchers.  Great!  1 out of 5 ain't bad?!

Elon Musk, in an interview with Walt Mossberg and Kara Swisher, mentioned that reusable rockets were needed to make space more accessible.  So he's working on the reusable rocket.  In my estimation, reusable stages just cover 2 of 5 standards that ought to be implemented by all launchers if we are going to be a people that live and work in space.  I don't mean low Earth orbit.  I mean the Inner Solar System, to include: the Moon, Mars, Venus, Mercury, Asteroid belt, and Near Earth Objects.  It's time we look at the big picture and make plans to inhabit this playground.  To do it we not only need to be scientifically smart but also economically smart in all things.

These standards are mostly from other people through the decades.  Many have realized we needed reusable vehicles to access space to include many science fiction writers.  Computerized tests came out of necessity from real life launch companies and government entities. Von Braun and his team implemented the multi-engine first stage to where if one goes out it could still get to orbit.  Maxime Faget came up with the idea of a rocket as a launch escape system for crews.  I just expanded the possible idea to non-human payloads.

I'd like to see other launch companies make new rockets that take on these standards.  I know a couple of start ups that are targeting the small satellite launch market that design their rockets with multiple engines on the first stage.  One of them is called Firefly.  We need to wait and see what happens.  For now, we have to make due with the clunker rockets as we see Falcon 9 develop and incorporate 4 out of the 5 standards I've stated.  Watch the other companies tremble in fear.

Wednesday, November 12, 2014

Lack Of Imagination

In the HBO miniseries "From The Earth To The Moon" the episode "Apollo One" depicts the investigation into the deaths of  Gus Grissom, Ed White, and Roger Chaffee and the loss of the Apollo capsule CSM-012.  They perished in a fire during a plugs out test on the launch pad.  In the episode, a Senator asks Astronaut Frank Borman what was the cause of the fire.  His answer was, "failure of imagination."  The idea was that nobody thought that the conditions of that particular test were dangerous.  They were all thinking of getting to the Moon.  NASA lost its innocence because of that incident.

Now we live in the wake of two commercial space disasters,  One commercial astronaut is dead.  One is wounded.  For all those who love space and commercial space, this is a time of pause.  One reusable space plane is destroyed.  One non-reusable rocket and cargo spacecraft with all of its cargo and research is also destroyed.  Accounting and insurance takes care of the rocket and the spacecraft.  The cargo must have had many customers with their hopes going to ISS.  Their projects may be insured but their hopes were dashed.

Many outside of the industry do not understand how these accidents happen.  There is a lot of anger out there on the net.  That's understandable.  There's a lot of fear and uncertainty.  That's also understandable.  Understand that these things affect everybody.  They affect all the CEO's of every space company to every kid who dreams about space and all the people and engineers in between,  We are all rattled even if we don't admit it.

Our innocence is gone.  Now, we will see how the space market reacts to it.  Investigations have to be completed.  They will find stuff that nobody may have suspected before.  Other stuff may be confirmed.  Plans will be made and implemented to avoid the same disasters.  These things must happen and will happen to move forward.  Moving forward is in the hands of the market.

Why are we doing this?  Why are we going to space at all?  Why did the crew of Apollo One and of VSS Enterprise die or get injured?  Why did Orbital Sciences Cygnus' customers loose their hopes?  Why did they even try?

They did it because they believe in a future that was better than this present one.  Space is out there.  We have been dabbling in low earth orbit for several decades trying to figure out how to proceed out in deeper space where higher radiation lives,  Out there where asteroids can be studied and mined and  where a moon can be settled.  Out there where a second planet can possibly hold life again (Mars).  Where we can study a dense atmosphere up close and figure out how to keep climate in check (Venus).

One of the biggest reasons is that life as we know it is a single point failure.  That means we know that if a big enough asteroid hits the planet it will wipe out all of life,  We know the size of the asteroid it would take to do it.  We know there are many asteroids much larger than such a size.  So in a real sense we are trying to save no just the human race of all of life from certain extinction.  It's not a matter of if but a matter of when.

My condolences to the family of the Virgin Galactic astronaut who died.  I hope the injured astronaut makes a full recovery.  I sincerely hope Virgin Galactic and Orbital Sciences are able to carry on with their programs.

Space programs should continue.  We must renew our hope in space.  We owe it to those who have perished and to our children and their children.  We must imagine again.

Remember the fallen:  Apollo 1, Challenger OV-099 STS-51-L, Columbia OV-102 STS-107, VSS Enterprise 4th rocket powered test flight.

PS I call the pilots astronauts as a way to honor them.

Thursday, September 11, 2014

Future Growth of Pressurized Cargo Deliveries Imagined

Ares V
NASA wants to build a rocket bigger than Saturn V, the Space Launch System 130 metric ton launcher.  This is to get the hardware they need to go to Moon, Astroids, and Mars.  It's basically a cargo hauler.  Now the Ares V, from the cancelled Constellation Program, was going to be a 188 metric ton rocket.  I had done some of my own calculations to realize that it could potentially haul the equivalent of 4 shipping containers to low Earth orbit.  Now, Saturn V was a 118 metric ton rocket.  Take a moment and thing about these numbers.  Think, also, about how much stuff people use every day.  Most of the stuff we use come in shipping containers.  Now consider a city in space.  The content of the many shipping containers that come by train and sea ships has to be launch off the Earth.  Has it dawned on you how much stuff such a city will need?  Has it dawned on you how big the rockets need to be to launch such stuff?  I came to realize that we are just at the very beginning of space colonization.  We have cargo carriers that supply the International Space Station (ISS) now that are both from government and commercial entities.  How much will the rocket launchers of the future have to grow to meet the demand?

ESA ATV
I looked at data shipped to the ISS in 2012.  I then reduced the number to tons per person per year.  I got 3.8 tons.  This is a pretty rough number.  I then did the same with the United States in 2012 and got 6.2 tons per person per year.  It would seem that the astronauts and cosmonauts are living on a shoelace compared the people on the ground.

If that is the case, our current launchers are, for all practical purposes, the smallest they can be to support 6 people permanently in orbit.  Falcon 9 (13.2 metric tons), Antares (6.1 metric tons), Ariane 5 (16 metric tons), Soyuz (6.5 metric tons), and H-II (10.1 metric tons) are the launchers for cargo to ISS.  This is our baseline.  On average, our launchers are 10.4 metric tons to low earth orbit.

If the astronauts lived like we do on earth, by how much will our launchers grow?  I calculate that our launchers would have to be 19 metric tons on average for 6 people with 6 launches per year.  You can see how that number already dwarfs our current launchers.

Now what if we had more than one space station or one big one, in orbit and a total of 100 people living in space full time?  If they live like astronauts do now, they would need 380 tons launched from the ground annually.  They will need launchers of 1,040 metric tons to launch 6 times a year.

Now if those 100 people lived like we do on Earth, then they would need 620 metric tons in a year.  The launchers would need to be 1,900 metric tons for 6 launches.

Can you imagine a 2000 metric ton rocket launcher?  That's about 17 times the size of a Saturn V.  That is huge.

You might say what if we increase the number of launches a year?  Won't that decrease the size on the average launcher?  Sure it will.  Let's see....  I calculate that for 100 people that need 620 metric tons a year and 20 launches, they would need average launcher size of 510 metric tons.  That's still about 4 times the size of a Saturn V.  Now 20 launches a year is quite a hefty schedule.  I suppose  if they spread out the load over 4 companies and/or countries it's not so bad.  Though a 510 metric ton rocket is quite large, I believe it is within the realm of possibility to accomplish.

You can see how the number expand with the increase of people.

This is only to LEO.  What about the Moon and Mars?  Well the numbers get exponentially larger.  So the rockets get exponentially larger.  The ones we have now are puny by comparison. That is why people have suggested learning to 'live off the land' and reduce the need for new cargo from Earth.  Even in deep space living off of asteroids and comets will be necessary.  It's just too much for us to lift that much stuff out of the Earth's gravity well.  The other thing we can learn to do is recycle, and recycle everything.  Air, water, waste (yes No 1 and No 2), soil, plant matter, and parts are things we need to learn to recycle if we are to live in space, or on the Moon, or on Mars.  New technologies are bound to be needed to this end.  Are we up for the challenge?

Friday, July 4, 2014

Could Atlas V Days Be Numbered?

Atlas V
The Atlas V was derived from what is called the family of Atlas rockets.  This family started launching in 1957, so Atlas V has a great heritage.  It has also been the main workhorse launcher for NASA and USAF satellites for about 12 years now.  As such, it was a rocket that was built strictly on government money.  It is now under scrutiny because its main engines, RD-180, are from Russia and Putin's administration is threatening to stop providing them.  The response to this is that the US government will put up money to research a new engine.  Wow!  Taxpayers are still paying full price for this rocket system.

With the advent on NASA COTS (commercial orbital transportation services) and CRS (commercial resupply services), the taxpayer has been getting a break.  NASA invested some money for the development of two launch vehicles and spacecraft from two different companies; SpaceX and Orbital Sciences.  These companies paid the rest of the development and own the risk for each launch.  In contrast, United Launch Alliance owns no risk to the Atlas V launches.  NASA deems the COTS and CRS programs successful and successful at reducing launch costs.  Will Atlas V survive in such a stark contrasted means of doing launch business?

Now, the Antares rocket is in a similar predicament with its main engines as Atlas V, though for different reasons.  The Antares main rocket engines are from the old Russian N-1 rocket, and those are of limited supply.  So Orbital Sciences is seeking a new rocket engine as well.  The difference is that they are flipping the bill themselves.  After all, they own the rocket.

 So we can see the inconsistencies for the taxpayer.  On one hand we have the old way of paying for the rockets as in Atlas V's case (the so called Cost Plus contracts).  That is, taxpayers pay for the launcher development, the launch service, and the launch risk.  Doing things the COTS and CRS way (services contracts), taxpayers only partially paid for initial development and for each launch service.  They don't pay for further development nor for the launch risk.

If the USAF got on board with paying only for launch services, they could save a lot of money, have companies competing for launches, and have national security all at the same time.  Sounds like the holy grail for the Department of Defense.  In my opinion, this would require a major change to EELV or even a replacement.  My reasoning is that the word 'expendable' might become a thing of the past since SpaceX is actively developing reusable multistage rockets.

I highly doubt that Atlas V could be converted to take on contracts for launch services only.  The reason is that it was developed under the attitude of limited savings as opposed to the drastic savings now sought after by the US.  No, Atlas V would have to be retired.  Of course engineers are pretty crafty guys.  If, by chance, Atlas V becomes reusable then I will rethink my position.  Otherwise, you really need to design a rocket with cost effectiveness in mind like Falcon 9 and Antares.

Now, SpaceX's Falcon 9 and Orbital Sciences' Antares do not have the lifting capabilities on Atlas V.  So for now, the USAF and NASA needs Atlas V.  Future developments from SpaceX and Orbital Sciences could change all that.  SpaceX is planning to make the Falcon Heavy which will eclipse the Atlas V by a factor of __ in launch capability.  Orbital Sciences is creating the rocket for Startolaunch that will go after the Delta II payload market.  Could there be any more developments in affordable launch vehicles?  I would say yes as long as the market holds up and funds become available.  In such a case, we may see the end of the Atlas family.  Atlas V still needs to get over a couple of hurdles.  One is, as mentioned before, getting new main rocket engines made in the United States.  Another hurdle is the Commercial Crew Development for NASA.  Atlas V is slated to carry one of two crewed vehicles to space: Dream Chaser lifting body by Sierra Nevada, and CST-100 capsule by Boeing.  What would the pricing be to take these to orbit by Atlas V?  Will such pricing be competitive?  Will such pricing be acceptable by NASA?  In other words, can Atlas V compete with Falcon 9 in the market?

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Mass Logistics To Space Idea

ISS partners keep a flow of small pressurized cargo craft coming to the station for just 6 crew and experiments. Progress, ATV, HTV, Dragon, and soon Cynus make up such a fleet. The ATV is the biggest carrying a max of 16,900 lbs or 7,667 kg. On land, we stack huge metal boxes carrying all kinds of cargo on ships, trains, and trucks.  These are shipped around the land supplying communities with effectively whatever they need. Commonly these are 40ft long cargo containers and can carry a max of 68,008 lbs or 30,848 kg. Imagine if commercial space takes off, and many space stations orbit around Earth, the moon, and deep space are made and manned. Having around 24 people in each station who need food, clothes, equipment sent to them and waste taken from them. How would you supply that amount of cargo? SpaceX's Falcon Heavy can lift to orbit almost the gross weight/mass of two 40 ft cargo boxes. So, I figure it could carry the cargo of one of these cargo boxes in a purpose made reusable stretch cargo capsule.  It would be a vehicle of mass logistics transportation.   What would such a craft look like and what would its operation be like?

Stretch Capsule concept made from Apollo CM pic
Why stretch anything?  The airline industry have stretched the bodies of its planes for many years to expand their payload capacity.  I remember first learning about stretched aircraft  with the DC-9.  It would seem reasonable to assume that commercial space companies sought out a solution for an increased capacity without reinventing the wheel all the way.  SpaceX's Dragon is touted as a reusable capsule.  They also want to make it to be capable of propulsive landings on the ground from orbit.  Thinking about those capabilities, you could stretch the capsule lengthwise (see pic above) to increase cargo capacity per trip.

Falcon Heavy (right) with Falcon family
A stretched capsule could launch from a heavy lifting rocket like the Falcon Heavy housed in a fairing.  Upon arrival, it could dock or be captured and berthed to a station.  The hatch on one end of the capsule would minimize space issues while attached to a station.  I don't imagine that it would be used for crew but only for pressurized cargo.  The station's Astronauts (Cosmonauts, or Taikonauts - if you like) would unload it and load it back up with whatever needs to be taken back down to Earth.  That could include experiments and even waste.  I've been considering the environmental impact of expending waste by burning it in the atmosphere.  Dealing with the waste on the ground might be more beneficial.  The capsule would detach from the station and de-orbit on its own merit.  The long heat sheild and the integrity of the cross sectional shape of the capsule would allow for a similar atmospheric re-entry as the Dragon.  Stretching the capsule longways also allows room for extra parachutes.  Dragon stores its parachutes on the side of the craft in a compartment.  The stretched capsule could have two or more compartments for parachutes.  Then comes the propulsive landing which would have a number of thrusters along the sides of the craft.  Several landing legs would also support this operation.

 The stretch capsule could be an intriguing idea for future engineers and space operations.  I think the alternative is to build newer and bigger capsules mostly from scratch.  It's not just the capsule that has to be designed but the manufacturing process as well.  I think a stretched solution would use the existing manufacturing process with some added parts.  In the end, this is just one idea out of many.

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Getting To Mars Depicted (Part 2)

In Part 1, we went through how much a trip to Mars costs in terms of fuel and hardware.  It takes 8 large rocket launches just for one manned mission.  That is about 75% the launches of the Apollo program to the moon.  Back then, the US Congress was willing to spend the money, but today they are holding back wanting to cut NASA's budget.  That's nothing new.  Congress has been cutting NASA's budget for at least the past 20 years.  A manned mission to Mars is quite a huge undertaking.  I know I did not talk about the radiation concerns or other crew health issues.  NASA likes to mention those.  They don't like to mention how much it would cost, and I think that is an issue that Congress and the public need to address.  The more the public knows about this issue the better.  How could we possibly reduce the cost?  Well, I've got 2 ideas.  Both of them are along the lines of mass transportation and reusable assets.  Reusable transportation assets and multiple manifests could provide more effective financing than one mission going alone by any one government space program.

Many Launchers for 1 Mission
Reusable Assets

When talking about reusable assets, a tug to take payloads from Earth orbit to Mars orbit and a reusable Mars lander/launcher come to mind.    For Mars, these assets have to be very sophisticated to include transferring of fuel and other consumables.  They would have to be able to be controlled remotely with some automation and manually by any crew.

I've talked about a reusable tug before.  For Mars, having a large tug that can travel many times between the planets could provide the means to take multiple missions on each trip.  Distributing the cost of the trip among several customers could make the trip financially possible.  I like to imagine such a tug as being based on the concept of the Saturn S-IVB.  It would have to be much larger.  I could have duo-propulsion: traditional chemical booster; electric propulsion such as ion drive or plasma drive.  Space.com has a great article on electric propulsion called How Electric Spacecraft Could Fly NASA To Mars.  A robitic arm such as the Canadarm 2 could provide a means of capturing and docking many different types of space modules.  Also it should be able to carry many modules to include unmanned and manned modules simultaneously.  Our module technology has become quite sophisticated so I don't think that would be a problem.  One of the biggest issues of such a craft would be electric power.  Solar panels are nice, but large ones would be needed to power the electric propulsion.  They also should be able to retract and deploy on command and often.  I expect that aerobraking maneuver would help reduce the amount of fuel needed for each mission.  Solar panels would need to retract for that maneuver lest they are damaged.  These panels would have to last a long time.  Another option, though less popular, would be giving the craft its own nuclear power reactor.  Of course, responsible handling of the nuclear material is a must; including a disposal plan for the depleted nuclear material.

A reusable lander/launcher is necessary. The idea of landing on an atmospheric planet is enticing and yet hard.  If you going to reuse the lander, it has to launch from the planet as well.  We've never created a craft like that before.  It would need a heat shield that can pop off and be replaced easily (by robotic means), a reliable engine, and large tanks for fuel.  After every launch back into orbit, it would need to be serviced and refueled for the next landing.  This craft is important because for one manned mission, NASA would use 3 landers and 1 launcher.  That's 4 vehicles.  Consolidating hardware complexity and weight into one vehicle should save on cost.  Using this vehicle for many missions should be a savings multiplier.

What do we really want to do on Mars?  Do we want to just plant a flag and walk around a go home?  No, many folks want to do many things.  From geology to colonization to terraforming, Mars has inspired many possible missions.  If we go with throw away assets, we won't be able to afford getting there but once in a generation if at all.  Mars should also only be the first step to exploring and exploiting the inner solar system.  Therefore, reusable assets are a must.  We must build an infrastructure.

Multiple Manifests

Mars Plane
 To spread the cost of trips to Mars and back, it would seem a no brainer to get as many different missions and customers to sign on.  It's like filling up the cargo hold and passenger cabins of a larch ocean fairing ship to make trips between continents across a large ocean.

Imagine multiple unmanned mission accompanied by one manned mission packed on the reusable tug that is about to depart Earth orbit.  These mission could be from all types: orbital, landers, rovers and sample returns.  The landers, rovers, and sample return missions can get loaded up on the reusable lander/launcher to get down to the surface along with the assests of the manned mission.  It seems they would all land in one spot.  Well, that could create the opportunity to have some planetary transportation services such as fast rovers and aircraft.  You can quickly imagine a multitude of missions and activity around and on Mars.

Spreading the cost for each trip and back from Mars among many customers seems reasonable.  Using reusable assets such as a reusable transportation tug and a reusable lander/launcher goes hand in hand with multiple manifests.  Such an effort could easily be a commercial venture.  Such an infrastructure could have the effect of researching the red planet in a much faster fashion than what we do now.  If regular trips to Mars every 3 years is sustainable then we would have established a permanent link worthy of colonization.

Monday, April 15, 2013

Commercial Moon Missions Imagined

Apollo took men to the Moon. Many unmanned craft of Russia and US and now other countries have made it to the moon. Soon to follow are commercial companies. Now, China wants to send Taikonauts to the moon. I don't blame them since a progressive space program can produce lots of research that helps their economy.  How would commercial companies go to the moon?  What vehicles would they need?  How should they differ from past manned missions?  Learning from Apollo, it's obvious that certain modules are needed to make any mission to the moon work.  You need a capsule to return the crew to Earth, you need an in space booster, or two, to get the crew and equipment from earth to the moon and back, and you need a lander.  Now, if your not going to the surface, you will need a space station made up of at least one module. It goes without saying that you need to supply all the fuel and other consumables for those vehicles.  Let's look at how these modules might be for a cool commercial effort that comprises of many missions to our natural satellite.

NASA's Orion MPCV
Why a capsule?  Well, let's put it this way, two superpowers chose the capsule to return crew from the moon. Even though Soviet Russia did not do a manned mission to the moon, they did plan for one. Capsules are concise and able space vehicles. I've heard space professionals say that wings are not needed in space. A space plane would have extra weight, and weight is the Achilles' heal of flight. When your traveling a half a million miles round trip in space, wings seem like a luxury.  So capsules it is.  What's great right now is that SpaceX is pushing the development of the capsules to have them set down on land with a propulsive landing and be able to be reused for more missions.  That is a far cry form Apollo days which relied extensively on a service module for crew survivability over the length of the mission.  SpaceX Dragon only has solar panels that are not incorporated into the capsule itself.  Everything else is.  Now, a capsule needs a beefier heat shield for lunar missions than just Earth orbit.  The temperature difference is about 2000 degrees Fahrenheit (1093 degrees Celsius) between reentering Earth's atmosphere from low orbit and from the Moon.  Currently, it is only feasible to have the capsule reenter the Earth atmosphere coming from the moon rather than trying to enter an Earth orbit.  We have not figured out how to go from Moon orbit to Earth orbit with a manned mission yet.  Though, in the future that could be a preferred way of doing business.

ESA'a Smart-1 ion drive to Moon
Trans Lunar Injection (TLI) was the maneuver used to take Apollo from Earth orbit to lunar orbit.  They used the upper stage of the Saturn V rocket to perform it and then jettisoned the booster.  Yes, I did not mention the Command Module docking with the Lunar Module because it's not relevant right now.  That may have worked for NASA but commercial efforts would require re-usability for many missions over time.  So to take care of the TLI function a reusable tug is in order.  Now this tug has to accommodate both manned an unmanned missions.  So, two forms of propulsion that exist should be used.  One is the traditional chemical booster and the other is the newer ion drive.  ESA's Smart-1 used an ion drive to power its way from Earth orbit to lunar orbit so its a viable technology.  The ion drive can be used for multiple reasons.  It has the power to navigate unmanned craft or failed manned craft (in the case of a dead crew) back to Earth so the loss of assets are minimized.  It can navigate the tug by itself to meet another ship for rescue operations.  It can speed up a manned mission to the moon, or other space bodies, by activating en-route all the way.  So it makes sense to have a dual propulsion system for our reusable space tug.  Of course, it will need a power supply and solar panels should do nicely.  A nuclear power system would be nicer since it could enhance performance and endurance of the craft, but radiating the crew or your cargo or ship is an issue.  Though, the nuclear system could power an artificial magnetic field that provides shielding.  The tug can be used to do all the burns to get from Earth orbit to lunar orbit, and it can get the capsule on its way back to Earth.  After detaching from the capsule, it can change course and get into an elliptical orbit and use aerobraking to slow down the craft to an orbit that is useful for refuel and the next mission thus saving fuel.

Apollo 12 - Intrepid Lunar Module

LEM was the acronym for the lunar lander in the Apollo program.  It meant Lunar Excursion Module.  Later, they just named it Lunar Module but somehow LEM stuck.  A reusable lunar lander would be more appropriate for multiple missions than the one time use LEM.  It could be refueled by the space tug in preparation of a landing and launching back from the surface.  It could be kept in lunar orbit in between missions.  One chemical engine should suffice.  The Apollo LEM was made up of two vehicles: a landing vehicle and a launching vehicle.  For our reusable one, it should be one vehicle.  Perhaps, two lunar landers could provide some redundancy and security for missions.

A single inflatable station module is good to have in orbit around the moon.  Such modules are being developed by Bigelow Aerospace.  It can serve as bigger space and more accommodations for crews, a port for the reusable lander, and a staging place for crew equipment and supplies.  One mission can bring it into orbit with or without a lander to begin with.  More station modules can be added to it as needed.  Boeing had previously suggested EML2 as a place for a lunar station instead of just simple lunar orbit.  I mentioned this plan in my post "Space Exploration Plans From Boeing".  I like the simple lunar orbit exclusively for moon missions over EML2 simply because its closer to the surface and it should take less time and fuel to get to.  Even if that is marginally true, its still viable over the course of many missions or even a campaign.

With capsules, space tugs, landers, and a space station; a commercial effort can carry out many moon missions for various customers.  Thinking about it now, I feel that having a space station around the Moon and a lander would be a good combination for several missions.  Humans have gone to the moon, and many more want to go for various reasons.  Finding way on how to thrive and not just survive on the moon is important for humanity.  We need to spread out beyond Earth.  The moon provides a first step towards that goal.

Thursday, March 28, 2013

Space Mining Operation Imagined

Deep Space Industries and Planetary Resouces want to mine asteroids and perhaps comets.  For years many people imagined that asteroids and comets were good for extracting minerals.  How would such an operation work in space?  We will look at what these small space bodies are made of, the scouts, the miners, and processors that are needed to extract the goods.

Stardust
To find out the content of comets and asteroids, NASA had some significant missions that provided answers.  Deep Impact spacecraft was successful in giving us analysis of the composition of comet Tempel 1 in 2005.  Stardust was a spacecraft that collected samples of comet Wild 2.  It finished its primary mission in 2006 and then had an add on mission to look at Temple 1 after Deep Impact's mission.   NEAR Shoemaker mission did some spectrography on an asteroid in 1997.  The findings of these missions are posted in the journal Science (membership required - a free one is available).  From what I read in Science articles, comets are full of water, carbon-dioxide, and hydrogen cyanide.  Asteroids seem to have elements to include iron, magnesium, silicon, and calcium, among others.  That's important because that is what is peaking the interest of companies to go and perform mining operations.

To really get a good understanding of what particular asteroids are made of, the companies will have to send out scouts.  Instead of a geologist, they will be remotely operated unmanned spacecraft.  Now, until recent history, unmanned exploration spacecraft either did flybys over specific routes, or went to orbit only one space body.  After their launch, which gave them the velocity they needed to get to their destination, they only had thrusters to steer themselves and no real main propulsion.  DAWN is the first unmanned spacecraft to have its own main propulsion via an ion drive.  Now its on its way to Ceres after orbiting and orbiting Vesta.  That's what you want in a scout.  It needs to orbit several asteroids by jumping from one to another.  Ion drives were first tested on NASA's Deep Space 1 mission with a mission manager that felt like Captain Kirk, Marc Rayman.  He also manages DAWN.



Marc is a pretty neat guy.  After the video interlude, let's get back to our topic.  As for finding the needed materials, and impactor and a spectrograph could be a quick way of determining the composition of asteroids or comets.  A scout could have several impactors.  This would be similar to the Deep Impact mission, but I imagine smaller and simpler impactors would be preferable.  Another way is to simply spectrograph the surfaces of the asteroids or comets.  I also would imagine marking the asteroids and comets by landing a small radio code transmitters.  This would be useful for the miners to come to them and find them.  Then on Earth, an automatic ground based system could track them without the need of an astronomer.

Deep Space 1
After marking the asteroids, miners come to extract the ore.  What would a robotic miner look like?  Now landing on an asteroid would seem tricky because of their irregular potato shape and the fact that they are spinning.  In 2005 Hayabusa landed on an asteroid and collected a sample.  A miner could do the same, but it must collect a lot of soil, do some preliminarily sifting (optional), and send the soil to a processing plant.  The container for the soil would have to be large and have its own service module (like a reusable space tug).  There should be several of these container ships going from the mining site to the processing plant.  They could be refueled at the processing plant and, if necessary, refuel the miner.

The processing plant should not be on Earth.  It should be in a place that is easily accessible from Earth and from deep space.  Earth-Moon, or Sun-Earth  L2 could be ideal places.  The processing plant would be a complex piece of machinery that perhaps would need humans to maintain it when it breaks.  Now such a plant would process the ore and have some material left over.  The waste material could be either sent to the moon or be collected next to the station, effectively making a ever growing pile of rubble that becomes an asteroid itself.

NEAR Schoemaker
After the ore is processed into some usable material, it could be sent to Earth, but why?  Well the simple answer is: that's where the factories are.  Yet, it seems rhetorical to get useful material in space to be only used on Earth where such material already exists.  That would be economically unsound.  An alternative is to take the material and make it usable for 3D printers to create whatever is needed for infrastructure in space and sell these items to other space companies for parts or new space structures.  These structures would use the elements from asteroids like iron, calcium, magnesium, and such.  The other types of product these processing plants could create would be consumables like water, oxygen, and hydrogen.  These consumables would be used by space stations, and even unmanned systems for fuel as well as the obvious.

Now, I've heard an alternate motivation for mining asteroids and that is for precious and rare minerals.  Whether such minerals exist in asteroids, I don't know nor have I read anything to that effect.  In such a case, bringing such material to Earth would be appropriate.  Such minerals could be sold in existing markets.

The use scouts, miners, and processing plants is the heart of my imagined space mining plan.  Now this little thought exercise is nice but is by no means the only way.  I just laid out a way that I thought would work.  It's fun to let you imagination run with a solution.  I even thought of an alternative which would make the miner and processor into one vehicle.  Yet, every plan will have different benefits and liabilities.  I'm sure you can come up with your own space mining operation plan.  It's a fun activity.